The Enigma

↑ Grab this Headline Animator

Monday, September 17, 2007

Good n Bad

To me the matters of good and bad seem like a sine curve when it comes to advertising. What's good is good, what's mediocre is mediocre and again, what's bad also seems good for people tend to get iconoclastic and relate to that bad piece of advertising, or sometimes these bad pieces of advertising appeal to the inner, concealed selves of human beings which we try to hide from the public eye.

Many people chastise Bingo for its unconnected ads, but then its a success story. To many people, it seems a bad piece of advertising, but if the primary motive of advertising is to boost sales, which I believe, one must admit Bingo is good! One real good, simplistic and wonderful ad to me seems to be the Reliance Classic Color Mobile with FM wala ad. The ad shows people grooving to the beats of latest chartbusters, and conveys the message damn well! That is one good thing to me...

Coming to bad things that click, when I asked people to write down some ads they liked and some they disliked, many of the girls said fairness cream ads were what they hated to the core, for they glorified fairness as beauty. But, to a marketer, these ads are runaway successes so much that it has made big companies roll out entirely new product lines catering to fairness creams for men segment.

Talking to bad advertising, one ad that I feel hasn't done justice to the product is Nokia 6300. Just the other day, a friend and I were discussing about the ad and while I felt the product exposure should have been in some other way, he felt that an ad is pointless when you are showing the product after 3 shots, and that too just a snapshot of it. There is absolutely no justification why they call it stylish. I have seen the phone, and I must say its a piece of art, but the ad doesn't tell me anything about it. This is definitely bad, according to me!

Again, Amul Macho ad has recieved lots of brickbats for its sheer eroticism, so much that the government has asked it to be put off the air. Many people dislike the ad for it seems B-Grade or even lower, but the sales figures speak otherwise. There are equal number of people who enjoy the ad as those who dislike it, as the article suggests. This suggests that though the ad is considered bad by a segment, if it has hit upon its target segment, it obviously is a hit. Again, by our assumption of a good ad being that which wins sales, this must be good.

So, when we judge ads, what is good and bad? What is a good piece of advertisement and what is a bad piece of it?! Should ethics be involved in advertising, or what should be the prerogative of advertising? As the Hutch Delhi Half Marathon punchline goes, Daudne ke liye bas dil chahiye! (You should just have a heart to run!), I say bechne ke liye bas dil chahiye! (same for sales!) So, I think we must all put aside our judgements about ads and just appreciate those ones that bring in the customers. After all, what is a good ad that doesn't win customers?!

Labels: , , , , ,

12 Comments:

At September 17, 2007 8:25 PM, Blogger Saraswathi said...

Oh ya the main purpose of an ad is to get higher sales and if dat is served I guess companies can relax no matter how many bad reviews they get about t he ad.

However as they say a thing of beauty is a joy forever. So a good ad does make the channel viewing on tv better ignoring the fact that it raises the sale or not :P

 
At September 18, 2007 10:43 AM, Blogger Sangeetha said...

You hit it right on! After all, the purpose of advertising is to increase the brand awareness, be it good or bad! Love it or hate it, but one shouldn't ignore it, to me that's the funda!

 
At September 18, 2007 10:33 PM, Blogger revatechnic said...

yeah thats what i really focus on when i do the promos and ads for the radio station... but for me it's all about 'audiolising'

 
At September 19, 2007 11:46 PM, Blogger Prithi Shetty said...

Hey Naresh,

Thanks for your good wishes ! :)

About the ads, I get a general feeling that most of them now-a-days are bekaar really. A lot of them actually. Choloromint, and lot more (cant remember them now that I want to list them).

There was a time, not very long back, when Indian ads were all humour or witty or atleast touching. Not anymore.

 
At September 20, 2007 2:33 PM, Blogger Sangeetha said...

hehe.....your blog seems to be attracting lot of female crowd :P ;-)

 
At September 21, 2007 11:41 PM, Blogger Prasoon said...

Like they always say - Any publicity is good publicity - works for Bingo as much as 6300 or say the Surf Excel "daag acche hain" ad :)

n btw, I love my Nokia 6300 too n everyone I have shown it to has fell in love with it :D ;-)

 
At September 21, 2007 11:55 PM, Blogger Prasoon said...

Saw the Bingo links and realized its Ogilvy n Mather's brainstorming : with all due respects, i commend their ad campaingn n so does this one have a meaning which i so far did not understand - my bad :)

 
At July 26, 2017 12:19 PM, Blogger Umang Bhalala said...


apple siri 310
Siri speaker 99

 
At July 26, 2017 12:19 PM, Blogger Umang Bhalala said...

iphone 8 OLED 33
OLED

 
At July 26, 2017 12:20 PM, Blogger Umang Bhalala said...

apple watch 3 rumors
apple watch 3 release date

 
At July 26, 2017 12:20 PM, Blogger Umang Bhalala said...

iphone 8 wireless charging

 
At July 26, 2017 12:20 PM, Blogger Umang Bhalala said...

install watchOS 4 Beta
os 4
OS4 apple watch

 

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home